How to Unlock

You will earn this after completing Initiation 4 We Sing once you escape the Talk Show Studio during the musical sequence. This part is more about timing and awareness than difficulty, so just stay focused and follow the path forward because getting caught up in the moment is easy, but you still need to keep moving.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this after completing Return 3 Local Girl once the chapter wraps up and the story transitions forward. This is one of the most content heavy areas in the game, so it is worth slowing down and exploring Watery thoroughly because you can pick up key tools like the screwdriver and crossbow while knocking out a huge chunk of collectibles in one go.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this after completing Initiation 7 Masks once you finish exploring the Oceanview Hotel. This chapter leans into puzzle solving and atmosphere, so stay patient and think things through because forcing your way forward rarely works here and taking a second to observe usually leads to the answer.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this in Return 3 Local Girl after defeating Mulligan and Thornton, and this fight is all about handling two threats at once. Focus on destroying the darkness orbs around the area first because the bosses cannot be defeated until they are gone, then deal with Mulligan up close before turning your attention to Thornton above. It can feel chaotic at first, but once the orbs are gone the fight becomes much more manageable.

How to Unlock

You can get this in Return 2 The Heart shortly after the General Store encounter, and while it is tied to exploration, it is very easy to grab if you are paying attention. Head into the room where the Taken broke through, look near the freezer, and open the locked case using code 739 to pick up the sawed off shotgun. It is a huge upgrade early on, so do not skip it because this thing absolutely deletes enemies at close range and makes fights feel way less stressful.

How to Unlock

You will get this during Return 5 Old Gods when you pick up the boltcutters as part of the story, so it is unmissable. Once you have them, go back and check any chained doors you saw earlier because they often lead to hidden areas with collectibles or useful resources, and it feels pretty great finally getting into those spots that were teasing you before.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this after completing Return 9 Come Home once Saga pieces everything together and finds her way out. Pay attention in the Mind Place here because connecting the clues is what drives progress, and if something feels confusing, slow down and review the evidence since the game is giving you everything you need.

How to Unlock

You will earn this in Initiation 9 Gone after defeating Scratch, and this fight is more about mechanics than raw damage. Hurt him until Casey locks him in place with the light, then quickly rotate both light bars toward the cage and step inside so he follows you into it. Timing matters here, so stay calm and focus on the sequence because once you get it right, the fight ends cleanly.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this in Initiation 2 Casey as part of the story, so it is completely unmissable. After the alley cutscene, move forward and pick up the flashlight and revolver near the body, which officially sets you up with the core tools for surviving the Dark Place. From here on out, light is your best friend, so get used to relying on it or the darkness will remind you why that is a bad idea.

How to Unlock

You will earn this during Return 3 Local Girl when you pick up the screwdriver as part of the main story, so it is completely unmissable. This tool lets you open certain locked doors and containers, so once you have it, it is worth remembering earlier locked spots you passed because they often hide useful resources or small rewards.

How to Unlock

You will earn this in Return 5 Old Gods after defeating Cynthia, and this fight has two clear phases you need to adapt to. While she is floating, focus on dodging her attacks and using your flashlight to clear projectiles, then unload damage when she drops to the ground because that is your best window to finish the fight. If she goes back into the air, just reset your focus and repeat, because patience here makes the fight way easier than trying to rush it.

How to Unlock

You can pick this up in Return 3 Local Girl while heading toward Coffee World through the forest, so keep an eye out along the path. Near a Hunting Shack, you will find a Cult Stash in front of the entrance, and opening it with code 527 rewards you with the crossbow. This weapon is great for saving ammo and landing clean shots, and pulling off a perfect hit with it feels very satisfying once you get the hang of it.

How to Unlock

You will earn this after completing Initiation 9 Gone once the chapter concludes in Perelman Tower. By now you should have a solid handle on Alan’s mechanics, so stay calm and focused during the final sequences because panicking is usually what gets you caught, not the challenge itself.

How to Unlock

You will earn this after completing Return 0 The Cult, which acts as the game’s opening chapter and introduction to the story. Once the prologue wraps up, the trophy will pop, so just focus on learning the basics and settling into the atmosphere because things only get stranger from here.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this after completing Initiation 5 Room 665 once you finish the hotel sequence and progress the story. This section can feel a bit disorienting at times, so take it slow and pay attention to your surroundings because the game loves to mess with you here and rushing will only make it more confusing.

How to Unlock

You will earn this after completing Return 2 The Heart once you defeat Nightingale and progress the story by the lake. This chapter is packed with collectibles and upgrades, so take your time exploring Cauldron Lake instead of rushing forward because you can grab useful gear like the sawed off shotgun and inventory upgrades that make the rest of the game smoother.

How to Unlock

You will earn this in Return 2 The Heart after defeating Nightingale, your first real boss fight, and it is unmissable. His attacks are all physical, so focus on dodging at the right moment and getting a few clean shots in before he disappears and triggers the storm phase. When that happens, just run and reposition instead of trying to be a hero, and repeat this a few times until he finally goes down.

How to Unlock

You will get this during Initiation 4 We Sing as part of the story, so there is nothing you can miss here. The game places the flare gun right next to the typewriter during the musical sequence, and once you pick it up, you will have a powerful tool for crowd control that can save you when things start getting chaotic.

How to Unlock

You will earn this after completing Initiation 2 Casey once you escape the Dark Presence in the Caldera Metro Station. This section introduces more of Alan’s reality shifting mechanics, so take your time rewriting the scene correctly because if something is not working, it usually means you need to change the story angle rather than brute forcing your way through.

How to Unlock

You will get this naturally early in Return 1 Invitation when you pick up your first Manuscript Page, so there is nothing to worry about here. These pages are part of the core progression and you cannot miss them, so just keep playing and enjoy the story as they start pulling you deeper into the mystery.

How to Unlock

You will find this in Return 5 Old Gods during the Wellness Center section, and it takes a bit of exploration to unlock. Follow Tor into the locked room, go to the control room, then use code 170823 on the nearby door, grab the missing knob from the reception area, and use it to access the workshop where the hunting rifle is waiting in a stash. It takes a few steps, but the rifle is worth it because it gives you strong, reliable damage at range when things start getting more intense.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this after completing Initiation 3 Haunting once you finish exploring the Perelman Tower and view the key footage. This chapter leans more into narrative and atmosphere, so slow down and take it in because it helps make sense of everything going on, even if it still feels a little confusing at times.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this after completing Return 7 Summoning once the events at Cauldron Lake play out. This section leans heavily into action and atmosphere, so just enjoy the moment and push forward, and if you have been switching between stories consistently, the pacing here will feel much smoother instead of everything stacking up at once.

How to Unlock

You will earn this after completing Return 6 Scratch once you force Scratch to retreat using the FBC lights. This chapter is shorter but still worth exploring a bit since you can grab the pump action shotgun here, and having it ready makes the tougher encounters ahead feel much more manageable.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this after completing Return 1 Invitation once you finish investigating and examining Nightingale at the police station. This chapter introduces you to exploration and early collectibles, so it is a good time to start building the habit of checking every area carefully because the game rewards players who take their time.

How to Unlock

You can grab this in Return 6 Scratch at the Bright Falls Sheriff’s Station, so make sure you explore the upper floor when you get there. Head into Sheriff Tim Breaker’s office and open the locked case using code 723 to pick up the pump action shotgun. This is one of the best weapons in the game, so do not leave it behind because it hits hard and makes close encounters feel a lot more manageable.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this in Initiation 2 Casey during a chase sequence with the Dark Presence, and it is unmissable. Just keep moving forward, avoid getting caught, and do not overthink it because the game wants you to feel the pressure here. If it feels intense, that is the point, so just run like your life depends on it and you will make it through.

How to Unlock

You will earn this after completing Initiation 1 Late Night once you escape the Talk Show Studio. This section introduces you to Alan’s mechanics, so take a moment to understand how the light and environment work together because getting comfortable here will make the rest of his segments feel much easier.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this after completing Initiation 8 Zane’s Film once you finish the events at the Poet’s Cinema. This chapter leans heavily into the game’s surreal side, so do not overthink every detail and just follow the logic the game presents because it usually clicks once you see how the scene is meant to play out.

How to Unlock

You will earn this after completing Return 8 Deerfest once you push through the chaos in Bright Falls and reach the key story moment at Valhalla Nursing Home. This section is more about survival and movement than exploration, so focus on getting through safely instead of fighting everything because sometimes the smartest play is just getting out alive.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this after completing Return 5 Old Gods once the chapter wraps up and your conversation concludes. This is one of the most content rich sections in the game, so take your time exploring Bright Falls because you can grab key upgrades like the hunting rifle, boltcutters, and extra charm slots while clearing out a ton of collectibles along the way.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this automatically early on when the game switches you between Alan and Saga, so there is nothing you need to go out of your way to do. After this point, you can manually switch between their stories at Break Rooms, which is a great way to control pacing, so if one side starts getting intense, you can always hop over and give yourself a breather.

How to Unlock

You will unlock this after completing Return 9 Come Home and finishing the main story of the game. Just follow the story through to the end and enjoy the ride because this is one of those games where the journey is just as important as the destination, and reaching this point feels well earned.

How to Unlock

You will earn this after completing Initiation 6 Return once the chapter wraps up in Perelman Tower. By this point, you should be more comfortable with Alan’s mechanics, so trust your instincts and experiment a bit because sometimes the solution is simpler than it first appears.

How to Unlock

You will earn this after completing Return 4 No Chance as the story pushes forward in Bright Falls. This chapter is more focused on progression than exploration, so just follow the objectives and enjoy the pacing change because sometimes it is nice to not worry about missing anything and just move the story along.

How to Unlock

You will earn this in Return 4 No Chance when you pick up the double barrelled shotgun near a body on your way forward, making it unmissable in Saga’s story. It shows up again later in Initiation 5 Room 665 for Alan, but that version can be skipped, so do not rely on it there. This shotgun is all about raw power at close range, so when an enemy gets too comfortable in your space, this is your not so friendly way of telling them to back off.